Critiquing: Episode #056 — Fasting, Resting, and Worship

March 11, 2021 | Ask NT Wright Anything – Premier

Fasting Practices — Christian Sabbath — Worship and Music — Personal Rest — Spiritual Discipline

---

Episode Assessment:

		Commentary
Degree of Accuracy	B+	The episode provides accurate historical and theological perspectives on fasting, Sabbath rest, and worship practices, grounded in biblical references and scholarly views. NT Wright’s expertise adds credibility to the discussion.
Degree of Coherence	B	The discussion flows logically, connecting various aspects of Christian practices effectively. However, the transitions between topics, such as from fasting to worship practices, could be smoother to maintain continuity.
Absence of Fallacies	B+	The arguments presented are largely free of logical fallacies. The episode avoids common pitfalls such as hasty generalizations or false dichotomies, maintaining a clear and rational structure throughout.
Degree of Evidence	B	The content references biblical texts and scholarly opinions, providing substantial evidence for the claims made. However, some points rely on anecdotal evidence, which may not be universally applicable.
Degree of Testability	C	Some aspects discussed, like the spiritual benefits of fasting and rest, are subjective and not easily testable by empirical means. The personal experiences shared by NT Wright provide insights but lack empirical validation.
Rational Confidence	B	The episode exhibits a high degree of rational confidence, aligning well with the evidence presented. However, some claims about personal spiritual experiences are more anecdotal and should be considered within that context.

Potential/Apparent Weaknesses:

1. Degree of Coherence

The episode occasionally lacks smooth transitions between different topics, which can disrupt the flow of the discussion. For example, after addressing the historical context of fasting, the conversation abruptly shifts to modern worship practices without a clear segue:

“So, yeah, what’s your views on fasting, Tom? I’m really grateful for these questions partly because I’m not an expert on this either in theory or in practice…”

The discussion would benefit from more deliberate transitions, linking the historical context of fasting to its relevance in contemporary practices.

2. Degree of Testability

The claims regarding the spiritual benefits of fasting and Sabbath rest are inherently subjective and difficult to test empirically. The personal anecdotes shared by Tom illustrate this limitation:

“But yes, in biblical times, in Jesus’ day, the great fasts that the Jews regularly kept were linked in Jewish tradition with the great times of desolation…”

While these insights are valuable, they do not provide a basis for empirical validation. The spiritual and psychological impacts of such practices can vary widely among individuals, making it challenging to establish generalizable conclusions.

---

Formulations of Major Arguments

Argument 1: The Role of Fasting in Christian Practice

1. Premise 1: Fasting is a practice mentioned throughout the Bible.
2. Premise 2: Biblical fasting is associated with significant events and spiritual discipline.
3. Premise 3: Contemporary Western Christianity often neglects fasting.
4. Conclusion: Christians today should reconsider the role of fasting in their spiritual lives.

Counter-Argument:
While fasting is a significant practice in the Bible, the cultural and historical context differs vastly from today. Modern Christians might find alternative spiritual disciplines more relevant and practical, given the changes in lifestyle and understanding of health. Emphasizing personal and communal well-being can achieve similar spiritual growth without adhering strictly to ancient practices. Moreover, the emphasis on fasting in the biblical context often related to specific communal and covenantal contexts that may not directly translate to modern individualistic practices.

---

Argument 2: Balancing Work and Rest in Christian Life

1. Premise 1: Jesus modeled the importance of rest and prayer.
2. Premise 2: Modern life often blurs the boundaries between work and rest.
3. Premise 3: Maintaining a balance between work and rest is crucial for spiritual and mental health.
4. Conclusion: Christians should intentionally create boundaries to ensure adequate rest and spiritual rejuvenation.

Counter-Argument:
The balance between work and rest is highly individual and context-dependent. Not all Christians may find the same practices effective. Cultural, economic, and personal factors influence how one can integrate rest into their lives. Flexibility and personalization of spiritual practices might be more beneficial than adhering to a fixed model. Moreover, the concept of rest and its theological implications have evolved, and what constituted rest in Jesus’ time may not align with contemporary understandings and societal demands. The emphasis should be on finding practical and meaningful ways to incorporate rest and spiritual reflection within the constraints of modern life.

---

Argument 3: The Nature of Worship in Contemporary Christianity

1. Premise 1: Worship is a central aspect of Christian life, involving various forms of expression.
2. Premise 2: Contemporary worship often focuses on musical events.
3. Premise 3: Traditional forms of worship included more diverse practices like liturgy and sacrament.
4. Conclusion: Contemporary worship should expand to include traditional practices to fully capture the essence of worship.

Counter-Argument:
While expanding worship practices to include traditional forms can enrich the worship experience, it is important to recognize the evolving nature of worship that responds to cultural and generational changes. Contemporary worship, with its focus on music, can also provide deep spiritual connections and communal experiences. Balancing tradition with innovation allows worship to remain relevant and meaningful to diverse congregations. Additionally, different communities might find various expressions of worship more engaging, and what works for one group may not resonate with another. Embracing a pluralistic approach to worship practices can foster inclusivity and respect for diverse expressions of faith.

◉ Addressing the Nature of Worship:

The Nature and Significance of Worship

Worship is a central concept in many religious traditions, often characterized as a fundamental way to express reverence and adoration for a deity. But the nature of worship raises profound questions about the relationship between humans and the divine. This essay will explore the significance of worship, examining whether the need to be worshiped is a virtue or a vice attributed to gods by over-projecting humans. We will also critique the analogy of God as a father figure, particularly in light of the practical absence of God in daily life and the portrayal of Heaven as a place of continuous adulation.

The Human-Divine Dynamic in Worship

Humans derive pleasure from the sycophantic loyalty of dogs, a relationship rooted in companionship and service. However, what kind of human demands such loyalty for its own sake? This question becomes more complex when applied to the divine. The need to be worshiped, when seen in a human context, often appears as a character flaw rather than a virtue. A person who demands constant praise and adoration is typically viewed as narcissistic or authoritarian.

When projecting these traits onto gods, one might argue that humans are anthropomorphizing the divine, attributing human-like flaws to beings who, by definition, should transcend such imperfections. This over-projection can lead to a portrayal of gods as beings who demand worship for their own glorification rather than for the spiritual growth and development of their followers.

The Father-Figure Analogy

Theists often depict God as a father with whom believers can interact as children. This analogy is intended to evoke a sense of intimacy, care, and guidance. However, the practical absence of God in the tangible aspects of daily life challenges this notion. Unlike a human father who is physically present and actively involved in the lives of his children, God’s presence is often described as transcendent and non-intervening.

Additionally, the depiction of Heaven as a place where the primary activity is the continuous admiration and worship of God seems to contradict the father-figure analogy. If we were to apply this standard to a human father, one who demanded incessant praise and unwavering devotion, we would likely view such behavior as tyrannical and self-serving. A healthy father-child relationship is based on mutual respect, love, and the nurturing of the child’s independence and growth, not on the child’s constant adoration of the father.

Virtue or Vice?

Is the need to be worshiped a virtue or a vice when attributed to gods? From a human perspective, such a need often aligns more with vice. It suggests an insecure and authoritarian character rather than a benevolent and omnipotent one. If the divine possesses virtues such as omniscience, omnipotence, and benevolence, the need for human worship seems out of place.

Worship could be understood instead as a practice beneficial for the worshiper, providing a sense of community, identity, and spiritual fulfillment. The divine, in this sense, does not demand worship out of a need for validation but offers it as a means for humans to connect with something greater than themselves. This reframing shifts the focus from the divine’s need for adoration to humanity’s need for spiritual engagement.

Concluding Thoughts

The significance of worship in religious life is a complex and multifaceted topic. While the demand for worship, when viewed through a human lens, may seem like a vice, it can also be reinterpreted as a practice that benefits the worshipers rather than the divine. The father-figure analogy, though comforting, falls short when scrutinized under the realities of human relationships and divine expectations.

---

We invite you to discuss this topic further in the comments section. Share your thoughts and perspectives on the nature and significance of worship, and let’s explore this profound subject together.